One Bite at a Time: Peppino’s in Brooklyn Earns a 7.9
Peppino’s Pizza in Bay Ridge scored a 7.9 in Barstool Sports’ famous One Bite review by Dave Portnoy. Discover what makes our Brooklyn slice a must-try for pizza lovers.
One Bite, Everybody Knows the Rules 🍕
Pizza lovers across the country follow Dave Portnoy’s One Bite Pizza Reviews to find the best slices in America. Recently, Peppino’s Bay Ridge location had its turn in the spotlight, and we’re proud to share that our pizza earned a strong 7.9 out of 10!
What Dave Had to Say
In his review, Portnoy highlighted what makes our slice special:
Great char on the crust that gives it that perfect New York crunch
Thin, foldable texture that stays true to Brooklyn-style pizza
Balanced flavor with “good everything” in every bite
The final verdict? A 7.9 rating—putting us in the “very good to great” category of New York pizza.
Why Peppino’s Pizza Stands Out in Bay Ridge
At Peppino’s, every pizza starts with tradition and passion. Here’s what makes our Bay Ridge pies worth the hype:
Fresh, quality ingredients – from hand-picked tomatoes to mozzarella that melts just right.
Authentic recipes – inspired by Italian heritage and perfected here in Brooklyn.
Consistency – every pie that comes out of our oven has the same love and care as the last.
It’s the combination of flavor, texture, and tradition that has made Peppino’s a local favorite in Bay Ridge for years.
Come Taste the Slice That Scored a 7.9
Want to see what all the buzz is about? Come down to Bay Ridge and grab a slice for yourself. Whether you’re a local or just visiting Brooklyn, Peppino’s is here to serve you pizza worth talking about.
📍 Peppino’s Bay Ridge
7708 3rd Ave
Brooklyn, NY
Final Slice
We’re grateful to be recognized by the One Bite community and even more thankful for our loyal customers who make Peppino’s what it is today. Our 7.9 rating is just the beginning—we’ll keep perfecting every pie until we hit that perfect 10.
